Monday, September 17, 2012

Jim Valvano vs Kurt Vonnegut


The worst speech I think we have watched so far was “How to Get A Job Like Mine”. I did not understand what the speaker was talking about for the entire speech and it just seemed like he was randomly talking to an audience about anything he could think of. He lacked the use of logos, which is what lost much of the audience. He did however, use pathos quite well and if I had known his ethos prior to watching the speech I would have understood it better. Kurt Vonnegut is a famous writer and his target audience was a room full of writers so they knew his credibility prior to the speech. I thought the speech was slightly entertaining to watch, but I was lost as to what the final goal of his speech should have been.
My favorite speech and one of the best I think we have watched so far was
Jim Valvano’s ESPY speech. It was very moving and entertaining at the same time. He used logos to promote the foundation he was starting, but also used pathos to add humor to his speech even though the topic of cancer was saddening. The fact that he was even standing up on the podium in his state made people respect him. He also was a great coach and was a victim of cancer so it gave him lots of ethos and respect from the audience. His speech was clear and easy to understand. I could also relate to him even though I did not previously know who he was before watching this speech.

No comments:

Post a Comment